In 1897, confused physician Edward J. Goodwin submitted a bill to the Indiana General Assembly declaring that he’d squared the circle — a mathematical feat that was known to be impossible. In today’s show we’ll examine the Indiana pi bill, its colorful and eccentric sponsor, and its celebrated course through a bewildered legislature and into mathematical history.
We’ll also marvel at the confusion wrought by turkeys and puzzle over a perplexing baseball game.
Please consider becoming a patron of Futility Closet — on our Patreon page you can pledge any amount per episode, and all contributions are greatly appreciated. You can change or cancel your pledge at any time, and we’ve set up some rewards to help thank you for your support.
You can also make a one-time donation via the Donate button in the sidebar of the Futility Closet website.
Sources for our feature on the Indiana pi bill:
Edward J. Goodwin, “Quadrature of the Circle,” American Mathematical Monthly 1:7 (July 1894), 246–248.
Text of the bill.
Underwood Dudley, “Legislating Pi,” Math Horizons 6:3 (February 1999), 10-13.
Will E. Edington, “House Bill No. 246, Indiana State Legislature, 1897,” Proceedings of the Indiana Academy of Science 45, 206-210.
Arthur E. Hallerberg, “House Bill No. 246 Revisited,” Proceedings of the Indiana Academy of Science 84 (1974), 374–399.
Arthur E. Hallerberg, “Indiana’s Squared Circle,” Mathematics Magazine 50:3 (May 1977), 136–140.
David Singmaster, “The Legal Values of Pi,” Mathematical Intelligencer 7:2 (1985), 69–72.
Zach Goldhammer, “Why Americans Call Turkey ‘Turkey,'” Atlantic, Nov. 26, 2014.
Dan Jurafsky, “Turkey,” The Language of Food, Nov. 23, 2010 (accessed April 21, 2016).
Accidental acrostics from Julian Bravo:
Adventures of Huckleberry Finn:
STASIS starts at line 7261 (“Says I to myself” in Chapter XXVI).
CASSIA starts at line 443 (“Certainly; it would indeed be very impertinent” in Letter 4).
MIGHTY starts at line 7089 (“Margaret, what comment can I make” in Chapter 24).
BAIT starts at line 12904 (“But as you come nearer to this great head” in Chapter 75). (Note that this includes a footnote.)
The raw output of Julian’s program is here; he warns that it may contain some false positives.
At the paragraph level (that is, the initial letters of successive paragraphs), Daniel Dunn found these acrostics (numbers refer to paragraphs):
The Complete Works of William Shakespeare: SEMEMES (1110)
Emma: INHIBIT (2337)
King James Bible: TAIWAN (12186)
Huckleberry Finn: STASIS (1477)
Critique of Pure Reason: SWIFTS (863)
Anna Karenina: TWIST (3355)
At the word level (the initial letters of successive words), Daniel found these (numbers refer to the position in a book’s overall word count — I’ve included links to the two I mentioned on the show):
Les Miserables: DASHPOTS (454934)
Critique of Pure Reason: TRADITOR (103485)
The Complete Works of William Shakespeare: ISATINES (373818)
Through the Looking Glass: ASTASIAS (3736)
War and Peace: PIRANHAS (507464) (Book Fifteen, Chapter 1, paragraph 19: “‘… put it right.’ And now he again seemed …”)
King James Bible: MOHAMAD (747496) (Galatians 6:11b-12a, “… mine own hand. As many as desire …”)
The Great Gatsby: ISLAMIC (5712)
Huckleberry Finn: ALFALFA (62782)
Little Women: CATFISH (20624)
From Vadas Gintautas: Here is the complete list of accidental acrostics of English words of 8 letters or more, found by taking the first letter in successive paragraphs:
TABITHAS in George Sand: Some Aspects of Her Life and Writings by René Doumic
BASSISTS in The Pilot and his Wife by Jonas Lie
ATACAMAS in Minor Poems of Michael Drayton
MAINTAIN in The Stamps of Canada by Bertram W.H. Poole
BATHMATS in Fifty Years of Public Service by Shelby M. Cullom
ASSESSES in An Alphabetical List of Books Contained in Bohn’s Libraries
LATTICES in History of the Buccaneers of America by James Burney
ASSESSES in Old English Chronicles by J.A. Giles
BASSISTS in Tales from the X-bar Horse Camp: The Blue-Roan “Outlaw” and Other Stories by Barnes
CATACOMB in Cyrano De Bergerac
PONTIANAK in English Economic History: Select Documents by Brown, Tawney, and Bland
STATIONS in Haunted Places in England by Elliott O’Donnell
TRISTANS in Revolutionary Reader by Sophie Lee Foster
ALLIANCE in Latter-Day Sweethearts by Mrs. Burton Harrison
TAHITIAN in Lothair by Benjamin Disraeli
Vadas’ full list of accidental acrostics in the King James Bible (first letter of each verse) for words of at least five letters:
ASAMA in The Second Book of the Kings 16:21
TRAIL in The Book of Psalms 80:13
AMATI in The Book of the Prophet Ezekiel 3:9
STABS in The Acts of the Apostles 23:18
ATTAR in The Book of Nehemiah 13:10
FLOSS in The Gospel According to Saint Luke 14:28
SANTA in The First Book of the Chronicles 16:37
WATTS in Hosea 7:13
BAATH in The Acts of the Apostles 15:38
ASSAM in The Book of the Prophet Ezekiel 12:8
CHAFF in The Epistle of Paul the Apostle to the Romans 4:9
FIFTH in The Book of Psalms 61:3
SAABS in The Third Book of the Kings 12:19
SATAN in The Book of Esther 8:14
TANGS in Zephaniah 1:15
STOAT in The Book of the Prophet Jeremiah 16:20
IGLOO in The Proverbs 31:4
TEETH in Hosea 11:11
RAILS in The Book of Psalms 80:14
STATS in The First Book of the Kings 26:7
HALON in The Fourth Book of the Kings 19:12
TATTY in The Gospel According to Saint John 7:30
DIANA in The Second Book of the Kings 5:4
ABAFT in The Third Book of Moses: Called Leviticus 25:39
BAHIA in The Book of Daniel 7:26
TRAILS in The Book of Psalms 80:13
FIFTHS in The Book of Psalms 61:3
BATAAN in The First Book of Moses: Called Genesis 25:6
DIANAS in The Second Book of the Kings 5:4
BATAANS in The Second Book of the Chronicles 26:16
Vadas’ full list of accidental acrostics (words of at least eight letters) found by text-wrapping the Project Gutenberg top 100 books (of the last 30 days) to line lengths from 40 to 95 characters (line length / word found):
58 / SCOFFLAW
75 / HIGHTAIL
58 / PONTIACS
52 / BRAINWASH
War and Peace
43 / MISCASTS
The Romance of Lust: A Classic Victorian Erotic Novel by Anonymous
42 / FEEBLEST
77 / PARAPETS
Steam, Its Generation and Use by Babcock & Wilcox Company
52 / PRACTISE
The Count of Monte Cristo
46 / PLUTARCH
57 / STEPSONS
A Study in Scarlet
61 / SHORTISH
The Essays of Montaigne
73 / DISTANCE
Crime and Punishment
49 / THORACES
Complete Works–William Shakespeare
42 / HATCHWAY
58 / RESTARTS
91 / SHEPPARD
The Time Machine
59 / ATHLETIC
Democracy in America, VI
89 / TEARIEST
The King James Bible
41 / ATTACKING
56 / STATUSES
61 / CATBOATS
69 / ASTRAKHAN
85 / SARATOVS
46 / TSITSIHAR
74 / TRAILING
48 / COMPACTS
58 / SABBATHS
Le Morte d’Arthur, Volume I
55 / KAWABATA
Vadas also points out that there’s a body of academic work addressing acrostics in Milton’s writings. For example, in Book 3 of Paradise Lost Satan sits among the stars looking “down with wonder” at the world:
Such wonder seis’d, though after Heaven seen,
The Spirit maligne, but much more envy seis’d
At sight of all this World beheld so faire.
Round he surveys, and well might, where he stood
So high above the circling Canopie
Of Nights extended shade …
The initial letters of successive lines spell out STARS. Whether that’s deliberate is a matter of some interesting debate. Two further articles:
Mark Vaughn, “More Than Meets the Eye: Milton’s Acrostics in Paradise Lost,” Milton Quarterly 16:1 (March 1982), 6–8.
Jane Partner, “Satanic Vision and Acrostics in Paradise Lost,” Essays in Criticism 57:2 (April 2007), 129-146.
And listener Charles Hargrove reminds us of a telling acrostic in California’s recent political history.
This week’s lateral thinking puzzle was contributed by listener Lawrence Miller, based on a Car Talk Puzzler credited to Willie Myers.
You can listen using the player above, download this episode directly, or subscribe on iTunes or via the RSS feed at http://feedpress.me/futilitycloset.
Many thanks to Doug Ross for the music in this episode.
If you have any questions or comments you can reach us at email@example.com. Thanks for listening!